Set your rebalancing rule in writing before you need it
Deciding when to rebalance in the midst of a crisis or euphoria is nearly impossible. Write down today the rules you'll follow tomorrow.
The biggest rebalancing mistake isn't choosing the wrong moment, but having no criteria at all. When your shares have risen 40% and your bonds are flat, your brain will tell you "this is going to keep going up, better to wait". When markets fall 30%, you'll think "perhaps I should wait until it bottoms out". In both cases, your investment discipline evaporates precisely when you need it most.
The solution is simple but counterintuitive: define your rebalancing criteria when you don't need them, that is, right now. Write them down, keep them in an accessible document and commit to following them mechanically. It's not about finding the perfect rule, but having a rule that protects you from yourself.
How to create your rebalancing rule
- Choose your method: fixed calendar (every 6 or 12 months), by weight deviation (when an asset deviates ±5% or ±10% from its target) or mixed (I review every quarter, but only act if there's a deviation greater than 5%).
- Write it down literally: "I review my portfolio on 1 January and 1 July. If any asset deviates more than 8% from its target weight, I rebalance by selling what's excess and buying what's lacking".
- Define numerical thresholds: none of this "when I see it's risen a lot". Set specific percentages: 60/40, 70/30, or whatever you've chosen for your profile.
- Keep it where you'll see it: in your password manager, in a note on your investment platform or in a shared document if you invest as a couple.
- Add an escape clause: "I only skip this rule if my personal situation changes radically (redundancy, inheritance, house purchase), never because of market movements".
In practice
Imagine your target is 70% equities / 30% fixed income. After a good year on the stock market, your portfolio has shifted to 78% / 22%. Your rule says "I rebalance if the deviation exceeds 5%". You're at 8%, so you sell shares worth 8% of your portfolio and buy bonds. It doesn't matter whether the news is good or bad: your rule already contemplated all possible emotions when you wrote it. Now you simply execute it.
Content provided for educational and informational purposes only, based on publicly available sources. It does not constitute financial, tax or legal advice, nor a personalised investment recommendation. Before making any decision, consult a qualified and registered financial or tax adviser who can assess your individual circumstances.