Volatility and drawdown: two different ways of measuring risk
Volatility and drawdown measure different aspects of risk. Understanding both metrics will help you better evaluate your portfolio and make more informed decisions.
When we talk about investment risk, many investors immediately think of volatility. However, there is another equally important metric that often goes unnoticed: drawdown. Both measure risk, but from very different perspectives, and understanding this distinction is fundamental to managing your portfolio effectively.
What is volatility?
Volatility measures the dispersion of an asset's returns relative to its mean. In technical terms, it is calculated using the standard deviation of returns, generally annualised. Higher volatility indicates that prices fluctuate more widely, both upwards and downwards.
For example, if an investment fund has an average annual return of 8% with a volatility of 15%, it means that approximately two-thirds of the time (according to normal distribution), its annual returns will oscillate between -7% and +23% (8% ± 15%).
Characteristics of volatility
- Measures movements in both directions: Volatility does not distinguish between rises and falls; it treats both as "risk".
- It is a statistical measure: It is based on standard deviation and assumes normal distributions of returns.
- Useful for comparing assets: It allows the risk profile of different investments to be compared in a standardised way.
- Relevant for the short term: It is especially important for investors with shorter time horizons.
What is drawdown?
Drawdown measures the maximum fall from a historical peak to the lowest subsequent point, before recovering. That is, it answers the question: "how much did the investor lose at the worst possible moment?"
For example, if you invested €10,000 in a fund that reached a maximum value of €15,000 but then fell to €10,500, the maximum drawdown would be 30% ((15,000 - 10,500) / 15,000).
Types of drawdown
- Maximum Drawdown: The largest fall experienced throughout the period analysed.
- Current drawdown: The fall from the last historical peak to the present value.
- Drawdown duration: The time it takes for an investment to recover its previous maximum value.
Key differences between both metrics
1. Temporal perspective
Volatility is an aggregate measure that considers all movements over the period, whilst drawdown focuses on the worst scenario experienced. A fund may have low monthly volatility but have suffered a severe drawdown at a specific moment, as occurred during the March 2020 crisis.
2. Investor experience
Drawdown better reflects the real psychological experience of the investor. Seeing your portfolio fall 30% from its peaks is far more tangible and emotionally impactful than understanding that it has an annualised volatility of 18%. Most investors do not feel "risk" when their portfolio rises sharply, but volatility does count those rises as risk.
3. Asymmetry of losses
Drawdown highlights a crucial mathematical reality: losses are asymmetric. If you lose 50%, you need to gain 100% to recover. A portfolio that falls from €100,000 to €50,000 needs to double to return to the starting point. Drawdown captures this asymmetry; volatility does not.
Practical examples with real data
The Ibex 35 case
The Ibex 35 experienced during the 2008 financial crisis a maximum drawdown exceeding 55% from its 2007 peaks, taking more than a decade to recover those levels. Its annualised volatility in that period was around 25-30%, but this figure alone did not convey the real magnitude of the loss suffered by investors who bought at the peaks.
Comparison between assets
Let us consider two hypothetical funds during a five-year period:
Fund A: Average annual return of 10%, volatility of 12%, maximum drawdown of 8%.
Fund B: Average annual return of 11%, volatility of 10%, maximum drawdown of 25%.
If you only looked at volatility and return, Fund B would appear superior: higher return with lower volatility. But drawdown reveals that at some point it fell by 25%, which could have led many investors to sell at the worst possible moment in panic.
Which metric should you use?
The short answer is: both. They are complementary, not mutually exclusive.
Use volatility when:
- You want to compare the risk profile of different assets in a standardised way.
- You are building portfolios and need to optimise diversification.
- Your investment horizon is relatively short.
- You work with quantitative or risk management models.
Use drawdown when:
- You want to understand the worst scenario you could have faced.
- You evaluate your real psychological tolerance for risk.
- You analyse active managers or investment strategies.
- You plan liquidity needs and cannot afford large falls.
Practical implications for your portfolio
As a Spanish investor, you should consider both metrics when building your portfolio. If you are saving for retirement 20 years away, you can tolerate greater volatility and deeper drawdowns. But if you are close to needing that money, a 30% drawdown just before retiring could be devastating, regardless of what the average volatility is.
Analysis platforms such as QCapital allow you to visualise both the historical volatility and the drawdowns of your portfolio, helping you make informed decisions based on a complete view of risk.
Conclusion
Volatility and drawdown are two sides of the same risk coin. Volatility tells you how much prices dance about; drawdown tells you how much you can end up losing from your best moment. Whilst the former is useful for technical analysis and comparisons, the latter connects directly with your emotional experience as an investor.
Do not ignore either. An investment truly appropriate for you must fit both with your tolerance for volatility and with your capacity to endure significant drawdowns without making hasty decisions. Knowing both metrics makes you a more informed investor and, probably, a more successful one in the long term.
Content provided for educational and informational purposes only, based on publicly available sources. It does not constitute financial, tax or legal advice, nor a personalised investment recommendation. Before making any decision, consult a qualified and registered financial or tax adviser who can assess your individual circumstances.