What are stablecoins and what risks do they pose for your investment

Stablecoins promise stability in the volatile crypto world, but carry specific risks that every investor must understand before including them in their portfolio.

Stablecoins have established themselves as one of the most widely used instruments in the crypto ecosystem, functioning as a bridge between traditional fiat currencies and volatile cryptocurrencies. However, their apparent stability can generate a false sense of security that conceals significant risks.

What are stablecoins

A stablecoin is a cryptocurrency designed to maintain a stable value, generally pegged to a fiat currency such as the US dollar or the euro. Unlike Bitcoin or Ethereum, whose price can fluctuate significantly within hours, stablecoins seek to maintain a constant parity, typically 1:1 with the reference currency.

This characteristic makes them attractive tools for multiple uses: conducting transactions without exposure to crypto volatility, maintaining liquidity on exchanges, facilitating international payments or serving as a temporary refuge within the blockchain ecosystem.

Main types of stablecoins

Not all stablecoins work the same way. There are four main categories, each with its own stabilisation mechanism:

Fiat-backed stablecoins

These are the most common and conceptually straightforward. The issuer maintains reserves in traditional currency equivalent to the stablecoins in circulation. For each token issued, there should be a dollar, euro or corresponding currency deposited in a bank account or in highly liquid assets.

Notable examples include USDT (Tether), USDC (USD Coin) and BUSD. These stablecoins depend entirely on trust in the issuer and the transparency of their audits.

Crypto-backed stablecoins

These use other cryptocurrencies as collateral, but due to their volatility, they require overcollateralisation. That is, to issue stablecoins worth €100, you might need to deposit cryptocurrencies worth €150 or more.

DAI, pegged to the dollar and managed by the MakerDAO protocol, is the best-known example of this decentralised model.

Algorithmic stablecoins

These have no tangible backing. They use algorithms and smart contracts to automatically adjust supply according to demand, theoretically maintaining a stable price. The collapse of TerraUSD (UST) in 2022 dramatically demonstrated the extreme risks of this model, causing losses exceeding $40 billion.

Hybrid stablecoins

These combine various stabilisation mechanisms, mixing partial backing with algorithmic adjustments. They seek to balance capital efficiency with greater security than purely algorithmic ones.

Main risks of stablecoins

Despite their name, stablecoins are not exempt from significant risks that can affect your investment.

De-pegging risk

The most obvious risk is that the stablecoin loses its parity with the reference currency. This can occur due to market panic, liquidity problems of the issuer or failures in the stabilisation mechanisms. During episodes of tension in crypto markets, even established stablecoins have experienced temporary deviations from their target value.

Transparency and reserves risk

For fiat-backed stablecoins, the crucial question is: do the promised reserves actually exist? Tether's history has been marked by controversies over the real composition of its reserves and the lack of complete independent audits for years. If an issuer does not maintain sufficient reserves, holders might not be able to recover their money in the event of a crisis.

Regulatory risk

Global financial authorities are increasing scrutiny on stablecoins. The European MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets) regulation, in the process of full implementation, will establish strict requirements for stablecoin issuers. Regulatory changes can affect the operation, availability or even the viability of certain stablecoins in particular jurisdictions.

Counterparty and custody risk

When holding stablecoins, you depend on multiple intermediaries: the issuer, the exchange where you custody them (if applicable) and the banking entities that hold the reserves. The failure of any of these links can compromise your investment. Let us remember that deposits in stablecoins do not have guarantees equivalent to the banking Deposit Guarantee Fund.

Smart contract risk

Decentralised stablecoins depend on code programmed on the blockchain. Errors in smart contracts or security vulnerabilities can be exploited by attackers, resulting in permanent losses. This technical risk requires that the protocol is rigorously audited and has demonstrated resilience over time.

Liquidity risk

Although the main stablecoins are highly liquid, in moments of extreme market stress difficulties can arise in converting large quantities to fiat currency at the expected price, especially on smaller platforms.

Considerations for Spanish investors

If you are considering holding stablecoins in your portfolio, bear in mind these specific aspects:

Tax treatment: Stablecoins are taxed like any other cryptocurrency. Gains derived from their purchase and sale are integrated into the savings tax base of the IRPF (Spanish personal income tax). Additionally, you must declare holdings of cryptocurrencies on foreign exchanges using the modelo 720 (Form 720) if they exceed certain thresholds, which you must verify for the current tax year.

Not bank deposits: Stablecoins do not offer the protection of traditional deposits. They are not covered by the Spanish Deposit Guarantee Fund, which protects up to a certain amount per holder and entity in the event of bank failure.

Prudent diversification: If you use stablecoins, consider distributing your exposure amongst various issuers to reduce concentration risk. Diversification does not eliminate risk, but it can mitigate it.

When does it make sense to use stablecoins?

Despite the risks, stablecoins have legitimate use cases for certain investor profiles:

  • As a temporary operational tool for movements between cryptocurrencies without converting to fiat
  • To access DeFi protocols that offer returns on loans (assuming their specific risks)
  • As a temporary refuge within the crypto ecosystem during periods of high volatility
  • To facilitate international transfers with lower fees than traditional channels

However, holding stablecoins as a long-term investment generally makes no sense for a conservative investor, who would obtain a better risk-return ratio with traditional bank deposits or money market funds.

Conclusion

Stablecoins represent a financial innovation with real utility in the crypto ecosystem, but their name can be misleading. They are not as stable or safe as their name suggests, and carry specific risks that go beyond mere price volatility.

As an investor, it is essential to understand what type of stablecoin you are using, who issues it, how it maintains its parity and what real backing it has. Due diligence and a critical perspective are essential before incorporating these instruments into your investment strategy.

Content provided for educational and informational purposes only, based on publicly available sources. It does not constitute financial, tax or legal advice, nor a personalised investment recommendation. Before making any decision, consult a qualified and registered financial or tax adviser who can assess your individual circumstances. Tax rules change each year: confirm current figures and rates with the AEAT (Spanish tax authority) or your adviser. This information applies only to residents for tax purposes in Spain.